Skip to main content Scroll Top

Local HVAC & Home Services – Erie County, NY (SEO Case Study)

A 4-month local SEO campaign in Erie County, NY that moved average keyword position from 76 to 48 and grew top-10 rankings from 1% to 35%.

BlueStar Home Services average keyword position improvement September 2025 to January 2026 - position trend rising from 76 to 48

The Challenge

A Buffalo-area HVAC and home services company serving Erie County needed to improve organic visibility across a highly competitive local market. When the engagement began in September 2025, the site was tracking 272 keywords with an average position of 76, only 1% of keywords ranking in the top 10, and a contact form generating 81 leads from 9,001 views.

The Approach

Over four months, the campaign focused on local keyword targeting across Erie County suburbs including Amherst, Williamsville, Cheektowaga, Clarence, and Tonawanda. Work included on-page optimization, content structure improvements, local keyword expansion, and technical SEO corrections.

The Results

By January 2026 — within one month of the engagement ending — the data showed:

  • Average keyword position improved from 76 to 48
  • Top 10 keyword coverage grew from 1% to 35% (4 keywords to 94)
  • Top 30 coverage grew from 3% to 56% (8 keywords to 153)
  • Contact form entries grew from 81 to 283 — a 250% increase
  • Form views grew from 9,001 to 90,758 — consistent traffic growth throughout
  • Rankings continued improving after the campaign ended, confirming compounding SEO gains

Before:                                                                                                                                                                            After:
lueStar Home Services contact form before SEO campaign - 81 entries from 9001 views      BlueStar Home Services contact form after SEO campaign - 283 entries from 90758 views

Before:                                                                                                                                                                   After:

BlueStar Home Services Erie County NY keyword rankings before SEO - average position 76, 4 keywords in top 10     BlueStar Home Services Erie County NY keyword rankings after SEO - average position 47, 94 keywords in top 10

Key Takeaway

SEO results compound over time. The upward trajectory that began in September continued through December and into January without additional intervention — demonstrating the durable value of foundational SEO work done correctly.